Changes between Version 27 and Version 28 of zzuf/bugs


Ignore:
Timestamp:
01/31/2010 03:31:24 PM (15 years ago)
Author:
Sam Hocevar
Comment:

link to crashing files

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified

  • zzuf/bugs

    v27 v28  
    11== The January 2010 media player debacle ==
    22
    3 [[Image(fail2.png,right,border=0,margin=5px)]] Yes, it’s a debacle again. While some players such as MPlayer had their stability improved, zzuf could again find bugs with most files, especially video codecs. All programs are the latest version in '''Debian amd64 sid''' as of 2010/01/14.
     3[[Image(fail2.png,right,border=0,margin=5px)]] Yes, it’s a debacle again. While some players such as MPlayer had their stability improved, others such as Xine plummeted. zzuf could again find bugs with most files, especially video codecs. All programs are the latest version in '''Debian amd64 sid''' as of 2010/01/14.
    44
    55Each of these bugs was found in '''less than 2 minutes''' of zzuf action, meaning that the “robust” cells are even less trustworthy than last time.
    … …  
    88 * “robust” means zzuf could not find a crash in reasonable time
    99
     10'''Note''': while these files cause the ''media players'' to crash, the code responsible for the crash is often found in the ''codec libraries'', especially FFmpeg’s libavcodec. They’re the software requiring attention.
     11
    1012=== Audio codecs ===
    1113
    1214|| || '''VLC''' || '''MPlayer''' || '''xine''' || '''FFmpeg''' || '''GStreamer''' || '''mpg321''' || '''ogg123''' ||
    13 || '''MP3''' || robust || '''SIGSEGV''' || '''SIGFPE''' || ? || ? || robust || N/A ||
    14 || '''Ogg Vorbis''' || ? || robust || '''SIGSEGV''' || ? || robust || N/A || robust ||
    15 || '''FLAC''' || robust || '''SIGABRT''' || '''SIGFPE''' || ? || robust || N/A || '''SIGSEGV''' ||
     15|| '''MP3''' || robust || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/lol-mplayer.mp3 SIGSEGV]''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/lol-xine.mp3 SIGFPE]''' || ? || ? || robust || N/A ||
     16|| '''Ogg Vorbis''' || ? || robust || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/lol-xine.ogg SIGFPE]''' || ? || robust || N/A || robust ||
     17|| '''FLAC''' || robust || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/lol-mplayer.flac SIGABRT]''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/lol-xine.flac SIGFPE]''' || ? || robust || N/A || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/lol-ogg123.flac SIGFPE]''' ||
    1618|| '''AAC''' || robust || robust || robust || ? || robust || N/A || N/A ||
    1719|| '''AC-3/A52''' || robust || robust || ? || ? || robust || N/A || N/A ||
    18 || '''Speex''' || ? || '''SIGSEGV''' || robust || ? || robust || N/A || ? ||
     20|| '''Speex''' || ? || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/lol-xine.spx SIGSEGV]''' || robust || ? || robust || N/A || ? ||
    1921|| '''EAC3''' || ? || robust || robust || ? || robust || N/A || N/A ||
    2022
    … …  
    2224
    2325|| || '''VLC''' || '''MPlayer''' || '''xine''' || '''FFmpeg''' || '''GStreamer''' ||
    24 || '''MPEG-1''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || robust || '''SIGSEGV''' || ? || robust ||
    25 || '''MPEG-2''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || ? || '''SIGSEGV''' || ? || ? ||
    26 || '''MPEG-4 AVI''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || ? || ? ||
    27 || '''MPEG-4''' || ? || '''SIGSEGV''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || ? || '''SIGSEGV''' ||
    28 || '''Ogg Theora''' || robust || '''SIGSEGV''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || ? || ? ||
    29 || '''WMV''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || ? || '''SIGSEGV''' ||
    30 || '''FLV''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || '''SIGSEGV''' || ? || '''SIGSEGV''' ||
     26|| '''MPEG-1''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-vlc.mpeg SIGSEGV]''' || robust || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-xine.mpeg SIGSEGV]''' || ? || robust ||
     27|| '''MPEG-2''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-vlc.m2v SIGSEGV]''' || ? || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-xine.m2v SIGSEGV]''' || ? || ? ||
     28|| '''MPEG-4 AVI''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-vlc.avi SIGSEGV]''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-mplayer.avi SIGSEGV]''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-xine.avi SIGSEGV]''' || ? || ? ||
     29|| '''MPEG-4''' || ? || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-mplayer.mp4 SIGSEGV]''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-xine.mp4 SIGSEGV]''' || ? || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-gst.mp4 SIGSEGV]''' ||
     30|| '''Ogg Theora''' || robust || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-mplayer.ogm SIGSEGV]''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-xine.ogm SIGSEGV]''' || ? || ? ||
     31|| '''WMV''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-vlc.wmv SIGSEGV]''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-mplayer.wmv SIGSEGV]''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-xine.wmv SIGSEGV]''' || ? || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-gst.wmv SIGSEGV]''' ||
     32|| '''FLV''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-vlc.flv SIGSEGV]''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-mplayer.flv SIGSEGV]''' || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-xine.flv SIGSEGV]''' || ? || '''[/raw-attachment/wiki/zzuf/bugs/rofl-gst.flv SIGSEGV]''' ||
    3133
    3234=== Testing protocol ===